Abusive Priests in University’s Past, Present

14 priests with connections to Georgetown University have been credibly or plausibly accused of sexual abuse. One known abuser was recognized as a professor emeritus of the university until Wednesday afternoon.

Letter From the Editor

 In bringing to light the abuse they have suffered, these survivors have called on all of us to take better care of each other.                 Will Simon, Issue Editor 

Dear readers,

The 14 priests named in this report lived and worked in all corners of our university — not lurking, but playing prominent roles in the academic, spiritual and moral development of thousands of Georgetown students. They were chaplains-in-residence and professors, friends and mentors, advisers and administrators: Their centrality to the Georgetown community cannot be overstated or forgotten.

Stronger than the influence of these 14 priests, though, is a nationwide community dedicated to the support and protection of survivors — and to preventing clerical abuse in the future. In writing and editing this report, we spoke to activists, journalists, lawyers, clergy and other experts, every one of whom was generous with their time and wisdom, not to mention courageous in their lifelong work.

14 Abusive Priests Found in Georgetown’s Past, Present

By Adam Shaham, Will Simon and Will Cassou

Since the founding of Georgetown University, its students have learned from, lived with and sought the guidance of religious leaders on campus. Of those leaders, 14 have been credibly or plausibly accused of sexual abuse, according to an investigation by The Hoya.

Their names are Fr. Engelbert M. Axer, S.J.Fr. Michael L. Barber, S.J.H. Cornell BradleyFr. Neil Carr, S.J.Fr. Martin J. Casey, S.J.Fr. Augustine J. Ferretti, S.J.Fr. Thomas M. Gannon, S.J.Fr. Jack KenningtonBernard KnothFr. Anthony McGinleyFr. Neil P. McLaughlin, S.J.Fr. Daniel C. O’Connell, S.J.Fr. William J. Walsh, S.J.; and Sr. Lisa Zuccarelli.

The credibility of accusations against each priest is based on settled lawsuits, the review of Catholic Church authorities or admissions of guilt. Each priest’s affiliation with Georgetown was verified through media reporting, public church statements or university archival material. Though the known abuse periods of three named priests overlaps with their time at Georgetown, neither this report nor the university’s internal review discovered allegations of abuse on campus.

Georgetown confirmed all 14 priests were at some point affiliated with the university in a March 13 statement to The Hoya. Yet the university has publicly recognized abuse allegations against only four. One retained the title of professor emeritus at Georgetown until this week.

The Georgetown 14

Daniel C. O’Connell

YE DOMESDAY BOOKE | Daniel C. O’Connell, Professor Emeritus 1998-2019

Engelbert M. Axer

YE DOMESDAY BOOKE | Engelbert M. Axer, Religion Professor, 1946-1949

Michael L. Barber

ILLUSTRATION BY ALEXANDRA BOWMAN/THE HOYA | Michael L. Barber, Hospital Chaplain, 1976-1978

H. Cornell Bradley

ILLUSTRATION BY ALEXANDRA BOWMAN/THE HOYA | H. Cornell Bradley, Campus Ministry, 1970

Neil Carr

JEFF ANDERSON & ASSOCIATES PA | Neil Carr, Undergraduate Student, 1937

Martin J. Casey

JEAN DENIS BEUCHER/PINTEREST | Martin J. Casey, Jesuit Community, 1973-2006

Augustine J. Ferretti

ILLUSTRATION BY ALEXANDRA BOWMAN/THE HOYA | Augustine J. Ferretti, Jesuit Community, 1973-2006

Thomas M. Gannon

WOODSTOCK THEOLOGICAL CENTER ARCHIVES | Thomas M. Gannon, Sociology Professor, 1983-1986

Jack Kennington

JEFF ANDERSON & ASSOCIATES PA | Jack Kennington, Researcher, 1981-1983

Bernard Knoth

HOYA FILE PHOTO | Bernard Knoth, Administrator, 1990-1995

Anthony McGinley

HOROWITZ LAW | Anthony McGinley, Professor, 1977-1987

Neil P. McLaughlin

ILLUSTRATION BY ALEXANDRA BOWMAN/THE HOYA | Neil P. McLaughlin, Hospital Chaplain, 1965-1983

William J. Walsh

BISHOP’S LATIN SCHOOL ALUMNI ASSOCIATION | William J. Walsh, Researcher, 1996-1998

Lisa Zuccarelli

DOMINICAN STUDIES | Lisa Zuccarelli, Nursing Professor, 1995-2003

 

As Jesuits Report Abusers, Experts Doubt Completeness

By Harrison Hurt

In the midst of an abuse crisis within the Catholic Church, the five Jesuit provinces in the United States released lists in December and January of priests accused of child sexual abuse. Yet the incomplete nature of these lists has sparked even greater criticism from lawyers and advocates, including lawyer Mitchell Garabedian, who has represented over 2,000 survivors of clerical abuse.

“The diocese and Jesuit Provinces want to appear as doing the right thing when they’re in fact doing the bare minimum,” Garabedian said in a phone interview with The Hoya.

Two ordained Jesuits with previous Georgetown affiliations and credible abuse allegations — Fr. Thomas M. Gannon, S.J., and Bernard Knoth — served in the Maryland Province of the Society of Jesus but did not appear in the province’s Dec. 17 report, even after another province’s report revealed their time at Georgetown four days later.

For two former Jesuits mentioned the report, Fr. Neil McLaughlin, S.J., and H. Cornell Bradley, the province omitted time both priests had spent on Georgetown’s campus.

And while the Maryland Province report named priests credibly accused of abusing minors, it mentioned no priests accused of abusing young adults, such as former Georgetown professor Fr. Daniel C. O’Connell, S.J., who settled two cases in 2003 and 2016 with survivors of his abuse.

EDITORIAL: Georgetown Silence Fails Survivors, Students

By The Editorial Board

Georgetown University has irrevocably harmed survivors and students by failing to identify and acknowledge former university priests credibly accused of sexual abuse.

University President John J. DeGioia named four abusive priests in Georgetown’s history in a universitywide email Dec. 17. Since then, The Hoya has identified 10 more, including two associate deans from the last 25 years and Fr. Daniel O’Connell, S.J., who remained a professor emeritus until Wednesday afternoon.

The abuse allegations against all 14 priests are a matter of public record, and most of their work at Georgetown can be found in the university’s own archives. Still, Georgetown has been willfully ignorant in recognizing the extent of its connection to clerical abuse.

Georgetown can no longer hide from its disturbing past in the clergy sex abuse crisis. The university must publicly acknowledge and condemn the other 10 abusive priests to allow the campus to move forward and take accountability for its negligence.

VIEWPOINT: Reconciling Jesuit Teachings With Abuse

By Grace Laria and Julie Bevilacqua

Our senior year began after the Pennsylvania grand jury report named 300 Catholic priests across the state who had sexually abused children over a span of 70 years. The sexual abuse crisis in the church has since permeated our ministry work on campus, which has spanned from organizing community reflections to pushing the university to revoke the honorary degrees of high-ranking clergy members accused of abuse and once lauded as members of the Georgetown family.

As active members in Georgetown’s Catholic community, we have both long been aware of a systemic lack of transparency and pattern of abuse within the Catholic hierarchy that have allowed the sexual abuse crisis to continue to this day.

News of Georgetown’s failure to publicly acknowledge at least seven Jesuit priests credibly accused of abuse who have had direct affiliations with this university, however, was a slap in the face.

VIEWPOINT: Continue Trusting Georgetown Jesuits

By Ryan Anderson

After The Boston Globe’s investigation of clerical sex abuse was released in 2002, many of us Catholics were shocked to learn that some of the priests we considered part of our family were abusers. As Hoyas, it is even more shocking and disheartening that some of these abusers were once beloved members of our Georgetown family.

As those of us who have close relationships with priests know, they are more than just spiritual leaders: They can be teachers, confidants and friends. Because of their spiritual role, we often hold their advice at the same or even at a higher regard than that of our biological family. Unfortunately, the abusive priests knew the amount of trust we placed in them. They saw a power dynamic and, rather than using it to further God’s will, used it to commit their sickening sins.

While nothing can excuse the terrible acts of the 14 priests who were once trusted by the Georgetown community, we should still welcome the Jesuits on our campus as mentors and members of our family and focus our efforts toward advocating for change within the Catholic Church to ensure that sexual abuse by priests never happens again.

Resources

On-campus confidential resources include Health Education Services (202-687-8949), located in Poulton Hall on the corner of 37th St. and P St., and Counseling and Psychiatric Services (202-687-7080), located behind Darnall Hall.

Additional off-campus resources include the D.C. Rape Crisis Center (202-333-7273), the National Sexual Assault Hotline (800-656-4673), the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) (877-762-7432) and SNAP’s Washington, D.C. chapter (703-801-6044).

If you or anyone you know would like to receive a sexual assault forensic examination or other medical care, including emergency contraception, call the Network for Victim Recovery of D.C. (202-742-1727).

To report sexual misconduct to the university, you can contact Georgetown’s interim Title IX coordinator (202-687-9183) or file an online report here. For more information, visit sexualassault.georgetown.edu. If you have information to share with The Hoya regarding this investigation, contact us at [email protected] or 421 Leavey Center, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C. 20057.

Methodology

All 14 priests named in this report were identified by cross-referencing Georgetown University’s archival material with publicly available information including media reporting, the August 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report and recent reports by Catholic Church authorities disclosing priests credibly accused of sexual abuse of minors.

BishopAccountability.org, a survivors’ advocacy organization that compiles and categorizes records and articles connected to abusers, served as an effective database from which to find more information about each priest. While a great deal of the information presented in this report is in credit to its meticulous work, every detail found on the website was verified by another source.

The report also draws from the accounts of national, regional, local and campus media outlets across the United States. News media were critical not only in providing detail about abusers’ prior work and the allegations against them, but also in creating a database of sources in the activist community.

The catalogues and records of the Catholic Church and Jesuit order were invaluable in identifying the locations of priests during each year of their ministry, including delineating between priests associated with Georgetown University and with the Woodstock Theological Center. The university’s collections of the Official Catholic Directory and catalogues of the Maryland Province of the Society of Jesus were especially instructive.

By studying telephone directories, yearbooks, alumni magazines, schedules of classes and other archival material, university archives staff in the Booth Family Center for Special Collections and the staff of Woodstock Library have worked tirelessly to ensure this report is accurate in its understanding of each abuser’s connection to Georgetown. Their persistent dedication to establishing the historical record was unmatched in both commitment and depth.

Further questions regarding the methodology of the report should be directed to [email protected].

Credits

Production Staff
Maya Gandhi, Editor-in-Chief
Yasmine Salam, Executive Editor
Catriona Kendall, Managing Editor
Samuel Nelson, Design Editor
Emily Shambaugh, Design Editor
Susanna Blount, Copy Chief
Amber Gillette, Photo Editor
Will Simon, Issue Editor

Contributing Editors
Will Cassou, Katherine DeMatteo, Myroslav Dobroshynskyi, Harrison Hurt, Anna Kovacevich, Mason Mandell, Sarah Mendelsohn, Yumna Naqvi, Sana Rahman, Riley Rogerson, Katrina Schmidt, Adam Shaham, Cady Stanton, Amanda van Orden