MCLAUGHLIN: Jim Harbaugh Needs to Drop the Act
Upon Further Review

We all know of that one dad who tries way too hard to act cool and hip around the kids in the neighborhood.  He hits the whip in front of his kids’ friends, blasts Bieber in the car and even downloaded PokémonGo so he’ll have something to talk to the teens about. He’s a cringe-inducing try-hard, and while he may occasionally be the cool guy that buys the high school kids beer, the try-hard “cool” dad is almost always one of the most universally despised people in the community.

Jim Harbaugh is the try-hard “cool” dad of the college football world, and this past summer, dubbed “The Summer of Harbaugh” by numerous media outlets, is the perfect proof.

This past spring, Harbaugh made it clear in interviews that he was all about reaching out to young talent in the upcoming summer. But what was initially meant to be a carefully orchestrated plan to curry favor with recruits quickly derailed into one of the most cringe-worthy media campaigns college sports has ever seen.

In recent years, college football recruiting has quickly shifted online as coaches have become more desperate to connect with 17-year-old talents. Harbaugh is no exception — having his own Instagram and Twitter accounts that he frequently uses. But it’s not the fact that he has a social media platform that’s the problem — it’s his content.

In the last six months, Harbaugh’s Twitter feed can best be described as “Trumpy.” In a cyber-attempt to raise his street cred with young recruits, he’s been in several Twitter arguments with other FBS head coaches. He even subtweeted Nick Saban for something the Alabama head coach said in an interview (worth noting: Nick Saban, winner of three national championships, chooses not to have a Twitter account).

When he’s not trying to show how much of a bad boy he is on the internet, Harbaugh tries to show how hip he is to the social scene. From Judge Judy to Big Sean, Harbaugh is constantly reaching out to rappers and celebrities. There’s even a photo of the old ball coach awkwardly grinning in a G-EAZY snapback with the caption “thanks 4 my new hat!”

But if social media flubs were his only crime, Harbaugh would be no worse that dozens of other clueless head coaches that try to connect to 18-year-old recruits on social media every day. In July, Harbaugh chose to be featured in a rap song titled “Who’s Got It Better Than Us?” He doubled down on the dork factor by choosing to be the main focus of song’s music video. To spare you the prolonged wincing and discomfort that comes with watching the video, it’s basically just two and a half minutes of Harbaugh driving a yellow sports car while awkwardly avoiding eye contact with the camera.

Nick Saban makes a big deal about flying across the country to visit a kid in California in person, because that’s a big deal. Jim Harbaugh however, is the kind of guy that has a sleepover with a high school kicker and documents the entire thing on social media.

Harbaugh’s try-hard “cool” dad persona has gotten so bad that even really awesome moves — like securing the first ever Jordan-brand football contract — suddenly seems irksome simply because it’s such a Harbaugh move to make. Everyone knows the Jordan brand carries a special allure with young athletes — so naturally Harbaugh had to have it.

Some may claim Harbaugh’s moves are simply indicative of the next stage in college football recruiting. Michigan did land the No. 5 recruiting class this past signing day (Alabama and all of Saban’s glorious old-school tactics sat at No. 1). But what can’t be disputed is that “The Summer of Harbaugh” has severely inflated expectations for the Wolverines, and has greatly widened the target on their back in the process. In trying to be the hip, cool coach of college football, Harbaugh has put himself and his program at the center of the college football stage. Harbaugh may have turned himself into a social pariah of the college football coaching world this summer, but winning can cure everything—even a try-hard dad persona.

JimmyMcLaughlinJimmy McLaughlin is a junior in the College. Upon Further Review appears every other Friday.

Have a reaction to this article? Write a letter to the editor.

One Comment

  1. Deliberate Reader says:

    Jimmy, it’s unlikely you had an opinion about the subject of your article until recently. What is likely is that you recognize using Jim Harbaugh in the title and body of your article will garner views, regardless of the merit of your writing or the depth of your thought. This is bandwagon drivel and on par with Bleacher Report and similar online news sites.

    Regardless of your recently formed opinions of the man, those that have worked with and for him over his college and professional career can easily disregard the kind of self-serving crap writers of your ilk pump out with such great frequency. Though I do not personally know the man, I have followed him and his brother over many years. There is a certain awe and respect for him from those that have an actual relationship with him. Conversely, those that only know him from his most recent rise in the media have mixed views: Harbaugh is great! Or, Harbaugh is over the top and rather annoying. I urge you to to give more thought and investigative energy into your writing if you aspire to something more than Bleacher Report or Gawker. Be better tomorrow than today and strive for excellence, Jimmy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>